GUARDIANS...NOT OWNERS
San Francisco Tribune; June, 2000
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors voted to amend official city
documents and from now on will refer to 'pet owners' as 'pet guardians'. This
doesn't change any legal status, but proponents thought the term evoked
warmth and compassion for pets.
...and speaking of "guardians"...
THE QUESTION OF CUSTODYCANINES IN COURT
Nightly News; July, 2000
He's got a face only an owner could love. His name is Guinness, a
125-pound rottweiler in the middle of a legal custody fight ó a big dog on the
forefront of a new field of law. Guinnessí case may finally answer the
question: has the world gone to the dogs?
Donít shake your head. Itís all true and the fur is just beginning to fly. Patty
Dalby is fighting in court with her boyfriend over who gets Guinness and his
canine friend Roxanne. Dalby is represented by an attorney who specializes
in animal law cases including dogs, cats, birds and even ducks. Under the
law, pets are pieces of property, but all of thatís beginning to change. Thereís
emotional attachment and value with our animals.
ìIt will continue to evolve until animals are recognized and courts recognize
that there is a different effect of losing a coffee cup then there is in losing
your animal,î said her attorney.
Emerging Trend
There must be something to this emerging legal trend. Two of the nationís
most prestigious law schools, Harvard and Georgetown, now teach courses
in animal law. And thereís already a 40 percent increase in lawyers ó 600 of
them are registered as members of the animal defense fund. Thereís even a
couple of books for all these new legal beagles to study.
ìThe reality is that many people consider their companion animals to be
members of their families, and thatís just a fact,î said Sonia Waisman,
author of ìAnimal Law.î
Itís probably inevitable. After all, Judge Wapner, who began the ìPeopleís
Courtî on TV now has a show called ìAnimal Court.î As for Guinness, he is
big, but not big enough for the book of world records. So to see what
happens to him, you may have to paw through a law journal, looking for a
dog-eared page.